One of the things that
is hard, as I discovered while visiting people in America, is to make
people realize how absolutely commonplace some things are. There is
such a contrast between what is accepted as “normal”. One example
is that, in Mozambique, littering is just what you do. That's because
so little of what you consume is waste that usually what gets thrown
out is a banana peel or maybe a pop can or something along those
lines. When our trash heap gets full we just take it out of town and
dump it wherever we want. Leaves, branches, wrappers, boxes, papers,
everything. There is no such thing as separating your recycling. You
are probably shaking you head saying that's ridiculous. You probably
live in the Northwest where you get chastised for putting a plastic
bottle in with the metal cans.
The point I'm trying to
make is you see recycling as responsible and normative. Kids in
Nampula see it as redundant; trash is trash. Just as you consider
getting a coffee from Starbucks every morning as
necessary and normal while I see it as addictive and prodigal.
I tell people different
things are in Nampula and they just can't quite fathom it. I say how
short life expectancy is (45) and it's shocking to them. I say how
short school days are (3 or 4 hrs) and its a surprise. I say how
widespread corruption is and it's alarming. I say how long people
walk just to get water and it's saddening. But to me it's just the way
things are and after a while I just accept it as fact. That's not to
say I feel like anything is any less tragic or sad, it is just
sometimes is a little lost on me because it's “normal” to life in
Nampula.
But those are mostly
just cold statistics. What is harder to accept sometimes is how
different behaviors can be. I want to stress the idea that something
can be normal without being right. If someone gets murdered in your
community, it can be a real shock. If you live somewhere like
Detroit, where folks are murdered daily, it can be numbing.
This year there was an
incident at the high school here. Five students (NONE OF OURS, I WANT
TO BE SUPER CLEAR ON THAT) came forward to say that a teacher at the
school had given them HIV. A sixth girl came forward to say that she
had slept with the teacher but had stopped recently and had not
tested positive for the disease. Classes were canceled for the day
and all the teachers were summoned for a meeting.
What was your first
reaction at hearing this. If you just read through it without
thinking, read it again. I'll wait for you....
Five girls got HIV
after sleeping with their teacher! My first reaction was disgust at
how these girls were probably pressured by the teacher in exchange
for getting a passing grade. Teachers will sometime select certain
people and pressure them and give them undeservedly bad results in
order to exact favors from them later on. These favors are usually in
the form of money or sex.
Then my second reaction
was that there was no way that five and almost six girls got
pressured. At least one of them would have to have stepped forward
before now. How overt was this teacher, and why had nobody said
anything until now. At least another teacher would be jealous or a
boyfriend of these girls would have found out. I was mad and deeply
saddened.
You really need to
understand that is is not even 10% as shocking as it would be where
you are living (assuming you don't live in sub-Saharan Africa). This
probably isn't even 2% as shocking as you think it is. Troubling and deeply sad, definitely. But not shocking. The reason is,
sadly to say, it happens quite a bit. These kinds of events flood the rumor
mill, but hardly makes the news as a scandal.
Then as each piece of
the puzzle came in, my opinion and emotions became more and more
confusing and layered.
We learned that the
teacher at the center of this had been kicked out of a high school
across town for almost the exact same thing. I even found a few news
stories online from the year before. That time he had been accused of
giving 4 girls HIV in exchange for passing grades at the end of the
year. Instead of being fired, he was just transferred quietly. To our
school. Lucky us. This man started to seem like a predator who goes
about quaerens quem devoret.
Then we learned that
during the morning when all of this unfolded, there was an assembly
held and the principal had all the girls come stand in front and told
anybody else that had information to come forward and say it in front
of the whole school. At this point any idea of privacy for these
girls was gone and everybody knew their names and faces. I was
horrified that these girls would be the ones vilified during the
situation and made examples of in front of the class. The object was
to subtly shame these girls and discourage anybody else from speaking
out.
Then we started hearing
from some of our kids that attend the high school. Two boys in
particular that have class with all these girls and their teacher
(they are all in grade 12). They say, in the case of at least four of
these girls, that is probably the only way they were going to pass
that year as they were mostly illiterate. But not because they were
being treated unfairly or had to succumb to these means in order to
pass, but basically because that was the way these girls had obtained passing grades since forever. It seems the girls went about quaerens
per quem ad devoret.
You see, while some
people try to get extra help from the teacher by asking if they can
stay after class or come in during lunch to discuss a reading or
solve some problem, these girls get extra help by on day one of the
school year asking questions like “What's your phone number? What
neighborhood do you live in? What hours are your wife not home?”
The boys said—and while this is not exactly the expression they
used it conveys the same meaning—that these girls were putting it
on pretty heavily.
So here is the summary
of what we have so far. Five girls get HIV from sleeping with a
teacher. Abhorrent in every way. Girls appeared to be trading sex for
passing grades. Not surprising in the least. The principal calls out
the girls and has them show their faces to everybody. Shocking. The
girls turn out to be the ones initiating with the teacher.
Disgraceful.
I talked soon after
with some of our girls to get their take on it. One that knows them
basically had the attitude that they got what was coming to them
and was glad because as girls get away with this it puts that much
more pressure on the rest of the girls to do the same and almost
becomes expected behavior. Others that didn't them were not surprised
and say that almost from day one you can spot the girls that, as they say
here, are running after teachers for some "special help".
The fallout from all of
this? The story didn't even make the news. If it did, thousands of
people would have been complaining wanting to know why the TV cameras
and journalists never came to their school, because that stuff
happens all over the place. The girls, they quietly stay put and are
finishing the rest of the year. And have HIV for the rest of their
lives.
The teacher, instead of
being transferred, just went from teaching during the day to teaching
night school. If anything, it might have been just the upgrade he
wanted. He stays at the same school, and gets to teach for half the
hours. People generally agree that the teacher came out a winner in
this situation because they say he went from having only six girls to
having at least twenty. Night school is full people that generally
just pay a bribe to pass a class and is notorious for sexual
promiscuity in every way shape and form. Teachers with other
teachers, students with other students, and teachers with students.
People will fail a grade five times in a row and keep enrolling in adult education classes not
because they want to pass, but because it is the equivalent of going
to a bar for a single person. If you want a hookup, and are looking
for others that want the same, you go to night school.
As you wrestle with
this story, keep in mind two things I said in the beginning. Being
normal or a common occurrence does not make it right. What happened
is wrong and sinful and detestable in every way. The second thing is
to not impose your thinking or attitudes on the characters in this
story. As deplorable as this situation was, the tendency would be to
say this teacher is a predator and even if the girls voluntarily got
involved with him, they were only giving into a sexist archetype and
were victims of societal pressures. I argue that the situation is more complex than that, and I
know many of you will disagree with me. But in saying that, I believe
it does not make what happened any less tragic. Just know that what
is normal here may not be so wherever you are reading this.